In AH, Mawlānā Ashraf Ali Thanwi answered a question regarding ‘Ilm-e- Ghayb and published it as Hifzul Iman. In this book, he has compared the. Hifzul Iman by Ashraf Ali – Download as PDF File .pdf), Text File .txt) or read online. Defending Hifz al-Iman against the Lies of the Innovators. By Mawlana Khalil Ahmad Saharanpuri| T+ November 8th, |.
|Published (Last):||6 March 2013|
|PDF File Size:||13.47 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||6.73 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
The Fatwa which was issued upon Mawlana Ashraf Ali Thanvi has nothing to do with denial of ilm e ghayb knowledge of the unseen which prophet had. He translated it word by word into Arabic and presented it to the scholars of Makkah and Medina. If any one says Imam Ahmed Raza Khan rh made interpretaion he should bring evidence in support of such a claim. Hazrat Shah Abul Khair Dihlawi found it utterly displeasing and said: At the gathering, the Ulema expressed their views on the paragraph in Hifzul Iman.
The actual hizul is this: However, since it carried implications of offending and disregard of honour and respect the ruling was thus given:. My grandfather stood and expressed his disgust at the book and said.
Please see news paper of Al-Muhannad Page 28, by ulama of Deoband. My grandfather mentioned the disgust he felt and presented a fatwa against the book. Such knowledge of unseen is also possessed by all and sundry Zayd, Amr ; even infants, lunatics and all the animals and quadrupeds.
Since he had great affection for my grandfather he invited him too. The original Urdu text of fatwa and hifzyl Arabic translation, both are online.
There is no more beating around the bushwhen I have brought the explaination by deobandi akabirs who knew what Mawlana Thanvee wrote and meant!. His wish was granted and he migrated to Madina thereafter.
Hifzul Imaan AH (CE) – Rasool ur-Rahmah (The Messenger of Mercy)
However, since it carried implications of offending and disregard of honour and respect the ruling was thus given: This is another lie. He made changes when muslim population read this and started abusing him!
Hazrat Shah Abul Khair Dihlawi found it utterly displeasing and said: Such knowledge of unseen is also possessed by all and sundry Zayd, Amr ; even infants, lunatics and all the animals and quadrupeds.
In sum, hifzlu words carried apparent insolence and offence hence to utter such words will be kufr:.
Hifzul Iman By Ashraf Ali Thanvi
The other side of story: The Deobandi author in an attempt to justify this writing says that. The blasphemous comment was used to degrade our beloved Prophet sal allahu alaihi wa sallam Best of Creation.
Your elders were upon our hofzul. Anyway, the sentence shows that he believes non-Prophets can also have ghaybi knowledge upon them. Please read this and show me where is Imam Ahmed Raza rh involved in this. The Deobandi author says that to make the meaning clear Mawlana Asharf hifzu, Thanvi made changes in the text!
So who is right? It is matter of choice upon deobandis that whose fatwa of kufr they want to accept? Who on this earth needs any interpretation of this statement?
It also looks as though Thanvi concedes that the text desrespects the Prophet sal Allahu alayhi wasallam. Then the legal ruling concerning such a person without hesitation is death. It also looks as though Thanvi concedes that the text desrespects the Prophet sal Allahu alayhi wasallam. Before Imam Ahmed Raza Khan issued the fatwathere was already fatwa by other scholars hitzul mass rally against this work of Mawlana Ashraf ali thanvee.
Hifzul Iman and Shaykh Thanvi
Elaborate and be rewarded! The Deobandi author says that to make the meaning clear Mawlana Asharf ali thanvee made changes in the text! He spent ten years there and passed away there in AH. Why did you oppose this? Since he had great affection for my grandfather he invited him too. He made changes when Muslim population read this and started abusing him! We have seen in my earlier post that many notable scholars who had no affliation with Imam Ahmed Raza khan rh said that these wordings of Mawlana Ashraf ali thanvee was indeed Kufr.
Click Here to read Large Scan Quote: This is such an ugly statement that oman muslim would like to read this statementforget about talking about those people who imman this belief or those who try to justify this. That text is not from the heavens, nor is it inspiration, like the sort whose beauty and respect has to be preserved by keeping every single word.
In fact, I think this is the only sentence in the whole book that was changed. The other side of story: